What Are You Afraid Of? A Guide to Dating After Divorce for Women Over 40
At the core of all dating problems is fear. This is especially true when you're re-entering the dating world after divorce.
When I met my husband, I was still working through my own fears about dating. I lived with the constant anxiety of meeting new people. And I carried the deeper fear that I would be tricked again—that I would believe a promise from another man who would then turn out to be the wrong man.
I was hypervigilant about what might go wrong. (Full confession, hypervigilance is still an everyday challenge for me. Ask my college kids who are required to let me know every step of their air travel to keep mom at peace.)
But the presence of fear didn't stop me from diving in and moving from divorce to dating to remarriage. And it doesn't have to stop you either.
Understanding Your Dating Fears After Divorce
Fear is a normal function of our brain. But when you don't recognize it for what it is, fear morphs into the disguise of "overcompensating certainty and confidence."
If you're a capable, financially solid, and successful woman over 40, your fears won't look like fear. Instead, they'll hide behind "logical" self-protective mechanisms:
Fear says: "Dating apps are terrible and there are no good men out there. All the profiles are disappointing."
What this really means: Even though I know dating apps are how nearly 50% of couples meet today, I'm afraid I'll fail and choose wrongly again. I always pick the wrong men, so I'll probably meet another narcissist and get stuck in another toxic relationship.
So you keep your guard up and swipe left on everyone. You judge and nitpick all profiles until there's no one left in your queue.
Fear says: "It's hard to meet anyone in person. No one goes out anymore. My town is too small, and there's no one on my level in this area anyway."
What this really means: I feel awkward and unsure of myself. I'm not attractive enough. There's something wrong with me. I'm afraid of being seen in person. I don't know how to interact face-to-face anymore. I'll be rejected, and I can't bear that.
So you stay home week after week. You put your worst pictures up online (so the guys "know what they're getting into"). You swipe left on everyone because "if they live in this town, they must be losers."
When Am I Ready to Date Again?
You're afraid that you'll throw yourself into the dating process only to end up empty and disappointed—again. You want to be certain that it will work before you show up for it.
But here's the truth: showing up is how you make it work.
Logically, you know that you want a partner, and there's someone out there for you. But your nervous system still seizes up at the thought of what could go wrong. This is where many women get stuck wondering if they're really ready to date after divorce.
You're ready when you can:
Acknowledge your fears without letting them paralyze you
Recognize low-effort men and not settle for them
Ask yourself important dating questions before getting too invested
Essential Dating Questions to Ask Yourself and Potential Partners
Before diving back into dating, ask yourself:
What did I learn from my previous relationship?
What values are non-negotiable for me now?
What patterns am I trying to avoid repeating?
And when you're getting to know someone new, don't be afraid to ask:
How do they handle conflict?
What does partnership mean to them?
How do they show up for the people they care about?
Working With Your Fear Instead of Against It
The answer isn't to eliminate fear—it's to work with it. The part of you that feels anxiety, worries, overthinks and ruminates about dating IS NOT BAD OR WRONG.
You don't need to get rid of it. It's your protection system, and you need it. But you need to learn not to let it run your life. It's overworking, and you need to prune it back.
You need space for the other part of you that's ready to create something bold and beautiful after divorce.
The key is to break the "only-doom-scenarios-exist" pattern of thinking:
I either date no one OR I date a narcissist.
I either stay with this low-effort man OR I stay single forever.
Recognizing and Avoiding Low-Effort Men
One of the biggest fears for women dating after divorce is ending up with someone who doesn't value them—the classic low-effort man. He's the one who:
Expects you to do all the planning
Rarely initiates contact
Is inconsistent in his attention
Makes promises he doesn't keep
Puts minimal thought into dates or your relationship
Remember that other possibilities exist:
You can be cautious about who you date AND meet wonderful men.
You can go on 50 first dates AND keep yourself safe from committing to the wrong man.
You can break up with the low-effort man you settled for AND find someone better suited to your love of life and adventure.
Your Path Forward in Dating After Divorce
Reframing your very normal, we-all-have-them fears is a non-negotiable step that helps you see the buffet of options open to you on your dating journey.
Once you know how to work with fear, you will be well on your way to creating your amazing, loving relationship—the one that's out there waiting for you.
Coaching offers a way to shift your emotions and reframe fear while you take massive action that accelerates your path to happily ever after.
Want More Help?